A Turning Point in the Fight to Protect New Mexico’s Greater Chaco Region

The Biden administration’s proposal to prohibit new oil and gas leasing and drilling in the area comes after years of exploitation that’s had devastating health and cultural impacts on Indigenous communities.
Diné activist Kendra Pinto sits on a high ledge near Twin Pines, New Mexico. In the distance, a well site emits a flare that can be seen and heard for miles.

Rob Zeigler

Last November, under a blazing blue sky, U.S. Secretary of the Interior Deb Haaland announced the Biden administration’s proposal to end new oil and gas leasing for 20 years within a 10-mile radius around Chaco Culture National Historical Park. For many of the tribal leaders, elected officials, and community members who were present, the announcement was very welcome—and long overdue. 

The Greater Chaco region makes up nearly 8,000 square miles in northwestern New Mexico and is home to thousands of Navajo and Puebloan families. The area is the birthplace of ancient traditions and ceremonies. It also includes the culturally and spiritually significant Chaco Culture National Historical Park, a UNESCO World Heritage site. 

Yet, for years, local residents have felt that the federal government wasn’t doing enough to protect their ancestral communities or cultural landscapes. They also think it ignored its duty to control unchecked oil and gas development or take meaningful steps to safeguard against climate change. So this most recent action offers new hope for activists, including those with Diné Citizens Against Ruining Our Environment (Diné CARE), a nonprofit organization that works with Navajo communities affected by environmental issues. Diné CARE previously and successfully partnered with NRDC and others on a case challenging the Bureau of Land Management’s authorization of permits to drill in the Greater Chaco region. “President Biden’s promise to protect not just the Chaco Culture National Historical Park, but the Greater Chaco landscape promises to end the practice of Diné communities serving as sacrifice zones for oil and gas development,” said Carol Davis, the group’s executive director, in a statement.

A map of existing active gas and oil wells (orange dots) near Chaco Canyon National Historical Park (green block, center)

Sources: Esri, HERE, Garmin, FAO, USGS, EPA, NPS


A Long History of Fossil Fuel Exploitation

Today, more than 91 percent of available lands in the Greater Chaco area have already been leased for industrialized fracking. As a result, there are about 40,000 oil and gas wells, and the administration’s proposed protections do not affect valid existing leases or permits.

“For nearly two decades, this region has been overwhelmed by oil and gas development, with no consideration to its negative impacts on local communities,” says Alison Kelly, a senior attorney and deputy director for regional campaigns at NRDC. 

That’s because when the Bureau first processed permits to drill these lands seven years ago, it didn’t look at the potentially harmful effects of fracking. Some of these permits were successfully challenged in court by NRDC and coalition partners, but as recently as 2020, the Bureau was still considering allowing more than 3,000 new wells in the area in a resource plan amendment for the region. That would be a profound injustice for communities already overburdened by a profusion of well pads, industrial wastewater ponds, pipelines, pump stations, and a web of access roads that are used by legions of trucks for daily industrial activities.

There’s also been a devastating health impact on local Indigenous residents, who have suffered from various issues, according to numerous investigations. In 2018, for example, the Counselor Chapter Health Impact Assessment (HIA) Committee conducted A Cultural, Spiritual and Health Impact Assessment at the request of local communities. The 80 Diné residents who participated reported an array of chronic symptoms, including sinus irritation, sore throat, nosebleeds, cough, headache, burning of eyes, joint pain, fatigue, and sleep disturbance. The majority of these residents lived​​ within a mile of one or more active wells, pipelines, or other gas and oil infrastructure.

Air quality monitoring also identified elevated particulate matter—which can harm respiratory and cardiovascular functions—and chemical exposure from well operations at four sites. This included the detection of formaldehyde, which can cause irritation of the nose, throat, and eyes; the EPA considers it a “probable human carcinogen.”

“People get headaches in the morning, we have cancer out here now, people are being diagnosed with cardio diseases, and asthma cases have gone up,” Kendra Pinto, an organizer with Diné CARE, told NRDC in an interview last November.

(Clockwise from left): Navajo activist and member of the Frack Off Greater Chaco Coalition Daniel Tso speaks at the Stop the Frack Attack Summit and March in Denver; A protest sign posted by community members; A BLM-BIA scoping meeting in Window Rock, capital of the Navajo Nation

WildEarth Guardians via Flickr, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0; Courtesy of Evalyn Bemis Photography (2)

The Demand for Justice

For years, the consistent approval of oil and gas drilling leases and permits in the face of such disproportionate impacts on local tribal communities alarmed Indigenous leaders. In 2016, alarm turned into terror when an explosion and fire at an oil production site near the Navajo town of Nageezi, New Mexico, killed livestock and forced 55 residents to evacuate.

Around the same time, the Frack Off Greater Chaco Coalition continued efforts to stop further oil and gas drilling. Members of that coalition, which includes NRDC, filed lawsuits, lobbied elected officials, and attended rallies. In 2019, some in Congress started to listen. They proposed the Chaco Cultural Heritage Area Protection Act of 2019, which made it through the House of Representatives but not the Senate.

For now, under the Biden administration's proposed protections, the Bureau would need to conduct more comprehensive environmental reviews, consult with tribes on potential impacts, and seek public comments before authorizing further extraction in the region. While this is a big step in the right direction, many tribal leaders, community members, and elected officials said they will continue to push for more permanent protections. “Ultimately, we're hoping that Congress will pass legislation that takes new federal oil and gas leasing in the region off the table permanently—and this latest action makes space for that process,” says Kelly.

According to the Bureau, Secretary Haaland is asking for the agency and Bureau of Indian Affairs to begin holding regional meetings in early 2022 that aim to create collaborative plans for managing cultural and natural resources in the Greater Chaco region. At the November event, Haaland addressed this effort, saying, “I’m calling the process ‘Honoring Chaco’ because that’s our obligation to each other and to the future.”

Davis echoed a similar sentiment. “The people in the Greater Chaco Landscape live by this maxim: What you do the earth; you do the people,” she said in a statement. “We are most hopeful that this action is a turning point where the United States’ natural resource management planning philosophy focuses on the protection of all living beings.” 

Tell Interior Sec. Haaland to help end destructive fossil fuel extraction


NRDC.org stories are available for online republication by news media outlets or nonprofits under these conditions: The writer(s) must be credited with a byline; you must note prominently that the story was originally published by NRDC.org and link to the original; the story cannot be edited (beyond simple things such as time and place elements, style, and grammar); you can’t resell the story in any form or grant republishing rights to other outlets; you can’t republish our material wholesale or automatically—you need to select stories individually; you can't republish the photos or graphics on our site without specific permission; you should drop us a note to let us know when you’ve used one of our stories.

Dispatch

As greenhouse gasses fill the sky, a progressive governor and worried residents take on oil and gas—the state’s most powerful industry.

Explainer

Biden’s Build Back Better agenda would cap them—while putting tens of thousands of people to work.

Dispatch

Native American activists in northwest New Mexico are putting up a firm resistance as the U.S. Bureau of Land Management hands over their homeland to allies in the oil and gas industry.

Latest News

The fact that senators tied to the fossil fuel industry are opposing her nomination is a big clue as to why.

Dispatch

Half a century later, a parent of the environmental justice movement is still standing up for low-income communities in the Southwest.

Dispatch

Federal rollbacks could leave New Mexico’s limited water dirtier by excluding up to 90 percent of the state’s waterways from protection.

Join Us

When you sign up you'll become a member of NRDC's Activist Network. We will keep you informed with the latest alerts and progress reports.